Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria

935 Pennsylvania Ave, Hagerstown, MD 21742, USA

About Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.3 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Jaime Brownell
    August 13, 2023

    My wife and I were at a Tractor Supply in Hagerstown, talking to the cashier about how we were looking to have pizza for lunch. He told us about this pizzeria and how good the pizza was. We decided to give a shot. We ordered garlic knots as an appetizer. They were delicious. They were crispy on the outside and warm and soft in the center. They were served on top of melted garlic butter sauce. Excellent! We ordered the meat lovers pizza with chopped red onions. We were very happy with the flavor and texture of the pizza. As former New Yorkers and New Jersyans, which we believe has some of the best pizzas in the country, we compare new pizzas from other states to NY and NJ. This was very close to being as good. Our server is the owner's son. He was very pleasant and friendly and made very good suggestions on what to try. The restaurant has approximately fourteen tables and was clean and comfortable. There is ample parking on their lot. Prices were a little above average for Hagerstown but worth it. We will be going back to try one of their pasta dishes and desserts. For those interested, they also serve wine. Highly recommend giving this place a try.

    Kyla W
    August 22, 2023

    Great staff and portions there was hardly a wait for anything amd the prices weren't bad.

    Heidi Maciulla
    December 27, 2022

    When we got home with our pizza, found it was burnt. Called to tell them, told by Mike, the owner's son, "When we get busy, the pizza can be burnt." No apology, no offer to make it right. Was a regular customer, not anymore.

    Brendon Bower
    September 10, 2023

    We have order here many times. Food is always good but let me tell you friend, this place has the best cannoli in the tristate area. They’re made to order and addicting as all get out.

    Samantha Turner-Realtor-MD, WV and PA
    July 06, 2023

    Food is amazing! But every time we've ordered the person taking orders is rude and short. Has limited my frequenting this place. It's a shame, because the pizza is good.

    Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria

    Our Address

    935 Pennsylvania Ave, Hagerstown, MD 21742, USA

    Tell Your Customers You're OPEN FOR BUSINESS!

    Let Us Know When We Can Start Helping Your Business Get More Customers.

    For more information on our listings, advertising, search and Internet marketing programs, and consulting services, please contact us today!