Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria

935 Pennsylvania Ave, Hagerstown, MD 21742, USA

About Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.3 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Corrie Barkdull
    June 28, 2024

    This place has delicious food, felt very friendly and is family owned. We ordered the large Greek salad, medium cheese pizza and they were both big portions and enough for our family of three. The crust and the sauce were so fresh and authentically Italian. Our servers were so kind and they were speaking Italian to each other. :) We loved finding this little gem on our road trip. Decor in the restaurant also very lovely and clean. Highly recommend!

    Jaime Brownell
    August 13, 2023

    My wife and I were at a Tractor Supply in Hagerstown, talking to the cashier about how we were looking to have pizza for lunch. He told us about this pizzeria and how good the pizza was. We decided to give a shot. We ordered garlic knots as an appetizer. They were delicious. They were crispy on the outside and warm and soft in the center. They were served on top of melted garlic butter sauce. Excellent! We ordered the meat lovers pizza with chopped red onions. We were very happy with the flavor and texture of the pizza. As former New Yorkers and New Jersyans, which we believe has some of the best pizzas in the country, we compare new pizzas from other states to NY and NJ. This was very close to being as good. Our server is the owner's son. He was very pleasant and friendly and made very good suggestions on what to try. The restaurant has approximately fourteen tables and was clean and comfortable. There is ample parking on their lot. Prices were a little above average for Hagerstown but worth it. We will be going back to try one of their pasta dishes and desserts. For those interested, they also serve wine. Highly recommend giving this place a try.

    Trish Marie
    June 22, 2024

    !!FOOD POISONING!! We got 3 meals, delivery by doordash. Seafood Alfredo, sauce tasted weird, had crab shells all in it, almost choked on a few pieces. Lobster Ravioli, sauce tasted weird, didn't taste like lobster, pasta overcooked. Cheese Tortellini, pasta undercooked, and sauce tasted weird. We ALL got food poisoning. I would not recommend. We were disappointed and a waste of $80 worth of food.

    Emma Peterson
    November 03, 2023

    My tortellini was buttery and rich and it came with a bread loaf in the side. My server was super friendly and had good recommendations. I’ll absolutely eat here again!

    William Wiesner
    March 15, 2024

    Everything was great, except they charged an additional fee to use your credit or debit card. In their licensing agreement with their credit processing company, they must agree to treat cards like cash. Called my bank and demanded charge back. If they continue and keep being reported, they will be dropped by their processing company and will no longer be able to accept cards, period. So sad. The food was great and service was great as well. Just greedy!

    Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria

    Our Address

    935 Pennsylvania Ave, Hagerstown, MD 21742, USA

    Tell Your Customers You're OPEN FOR BUSINESS!

    Let Us Know When We Can Start Helping Your Business Get More Customers.

    For more information on our listings, advertising, search and Internet marketing programs, and consulting services, please contact us today!