This is a nice place and I was quite surprised. Our waiter had wonderful customer service skills. We ordered a stromboli and an Amalfi salad which was delicious. The balsamic dressing was fabulous. I only wish I had room to try some of their desserts.
Heidi Maciulla
-
December 27, 2022
When we got home with our pizza, found it was burnt. Called to tell them, told by Mike, the owner's son, "When we get busy, the pizza can be burnt." No apology, no offer to make it right. Was a regular customer, not anymore.
Roi Varrone
-
November 23, 2022
Ordered the Fettuccine Alfredo with Broccoli for delivery. Awful, just awful, as a real Italian I am insulted, disgusted, how dare you. You know what you did.
Anne Thomas
-
December 15, 2022
Absolutely wretched. The people at my church love this place, so I have to eat here almost every Sunday. I'm vegan, so I ordered the spaghetti, and it had the worst red sauce I have ever eaten, thin and an odd orange color. I tried the pizza without cheese; it was ok, but I thought it was overpriced. I'm just going to get salads from now on.
robert geer
-
February 03, 2023
I'm impressed every time we go here. Pasta awesome. Pizza huge. Cheesesteak delicious. Even the desserts are good. Just don't order the raspberry cheesecake. Ask your waitress why. Lol. Plenty of parking. Decent bathroom. Would definitely go again and again. Mmmmmmmmmmmmmm
Our Address
935 Pennsylvania Ave, Hagerstown, MD 21742, USA
Claim Listing: Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
This is a nice place and I was quite surprised. Our waiter had wonderful customer service skills. We ordered a stromboli and an Amalfi salad which was delicious. The balsamic dressing was fabulous. I only wish I had room to try some of their desserts.
When we got home with our pizza, found it was burnt. Called to tell them, told by Mike, the owner's son, "When we get busy, the pizza can be burnt." No apology, no offer to make it right. Was a regular customer, not anymore.
Ordered the Fettuccine Alfredo with Broccoli for delivery. Awful, just awful, as a real Italian I am insulted, disgusted, how dare you. You know what you did.
Absolutely wretched. The people at my church love this place, so I have to eat here almost every Sunday. I'm vegan, so I ordered the spaghetti, and it had the worst red sauce I have ever eaten, thin and an odd orange color. I tried the pizza without cheese; it was ok, but I thought it was overpriced. I'm just going to get salads from now on.
I'm impressed every time we go here. Pasta awesome. Pizza huge. Cheesesteak delicious. Even the desserts are good. Just don't order the raspberry cheesecake. Ask your waitress why. Lol. Plenty of parking. Decent bathroom. Would definitely go again and again. Mmmmmmmmmmmmmm