Italia New York Pizza 2 – Adamstown

5549 Mountville Rd, Adamstown, MD 21710, USA

About Italia New York Pizza 2 – Adamstown

4.5 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Stephen C
    -
    April 12, 2024

    Fantastic NY style pizza, crispy chewy crust the way it should be. Friendly staff and good prices.

    Camilo Toro
    -
    August 12, 2023

    Don’t want to be overly critical on this review because their Walkersville location is pretty good and I have had solid experiences there before which led me to try out the Adamstown location. I was very surprised with the price I got two large pizzas with 5 toppings each and 2 chicken Caesar salads for my family and I was never told the final price over the phone. I get to the store and it was $88.50. I usually get the same order at Pizza Blitz in Frederick and it is at least 20-30$ cheaper and so much better. The pizza here is awful for the price, any digiorno or Pizza Hut pizza is better. The pizza really didn’t look half bad from first glance, things changed after the first bite. The crust was burnt and it tasted and had the consistency of cardboard. The sauce was very bland. The toppings were okay but I got broccoli on my pizza which I threw away after two slices and the broccoli tasted like it was microwaved in a plastic bag and it was still wet and half frozen. As for the Chicken Caesar salad it might have been worse than the pizza. Wilted lettuce everywhere, croutons were old and the chicken had zero flavor and was over cooked, tough to bite into, and not fresh. Barely any Caesar dressing given on the side either. This is my first time writing a review on an eatery in my life but my experience at Italia in Adamstown was that bad that I felt the need to write this review. Something has to be done with the high prices and the overall product asap.

    David Fritz
    -
    June 20, 2024

    My new lunch spot, I have had several menue items, steak and cheese with the works, italian cold cut, cheese pizza , fris.... all very good , great sub rolls and the pizza is a great NY slice... these guys are very polite and down to earth... not just great food but great service.

    Ari Kon
    -
    November 03, 2023

    Stopped by with my wife and got the large pizza, the crust and cheese were perfect, the sauce was pretty bland, a little oregano and garlic goes a long way. As far as the inside could use some paint

    Allen Nuccio
    -
    May 10, 2021

    Legitimately the best pizza in the Frederick area, and I have tried just about all of them. You wouldn't think given the location and the fact that this particular location has housed numerous other failed Italian restaurants, but this place is actually great. The crust is perfect, the sauce is sweet and tangy (applied in the perfect amount) and the cheese is delicious. All the toppings are great, everything seems fresh. It all comes together incredibly well with just the appropriate amount of oiliness to finish it off. Their other offerings are also good, but their pies are fantastic. One recommendation for the owners--work with the delivery drivers to make sure the pies stay level. The cheese often slides around on them and is out of sorts when it arrives. Otherwise, awesome work.

    Italia New York Pizza 2 – Adamstown

    Our Address

    5549 Mountville Rd, Adamstown, MD 21710, USA

    Tell Your Customers You're OPEN FOR BUSINESS!

    Let Us Know When We Can Start Helping Your Business Get More Customers.

    For more information on our listings, advertising, search and Internet marketing programs, and consulting services, please contact us today!